Top 5 Luxury Consignment Shops in Lakewood Ranch
Find the best Lakewood Ranch consignment boutiques for authenticated designer pieces, great deals, and sustainable shopping.
Lakewood Ranch offers an impressive selection of luxury consignment shops where you can find high-end designer items at reduced prices. From clothing and accessories to furniture and handmade goods, these stores combine savings with eco-conscious shopping. Here's a quick look at the top five:
- Laura Jean's Consignments: Known for luxury brands like Dolce & Gabbana and Golden Goose, with prices 40%-75% below retail. Offers inclusive sizing and a boutique shopping experience.
- Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch: Features trendy designer pieces from brands such as Amanda Uprichard and Emily McCarthy, with prices ranging from $125 to $375. Offers private shopping parties and concierge delivery.
- Burns Mercantile: Specializes in artisanal goods and outdoor-inspired apparel, with prices starting as low as $4 for small items.
- Woman's Exchange Inc.: A 15,000 sq. ft. non-profit showroom offering items like Gucci handbags and Tiffany silver. Proceeds support local arts and scholarships.
- The Closet of Sarasota: Focuses on authenticated designer pieces with flexible payment options and a growing online presence.
These stores cater to a variety of tastes and budgets, making luxury shopping more accessible while promoting eco-friendly practices.
Lakewood Ranch Luxury Consignment Shops Comparison Guide
1. Laura Jean's Consignments
Specialties in Luxury Brands
Laura Jean's Consignments has earned its reputation for offering an impressive collection of luxury items. As owner Lindsey McDaniel puts it, "This is what I think consignment is - finding the cream of the crop." The store focuses on standout designer pieces from top brands like Dolce & Gabbana, Self-Portrait, and Golden Goose. Shoppers can explore a wide range of high-end items, including dresses, handbags, luxury shoes, and accessories. You'll also find trendy jewelry, scarves, and belts, alongside a curated selection of new boutique clothing.
One of the shop's defining features is its inclusive sizing, with options ranging from size 00 to 26. This effort to cater to diverse customers is rare in the luxury consignment world. Family-owned since 1992 and now managed by the founder's daughter, Laura Jean's maintains rigorous quality standards, ensuring every piece meets high expectations.
Price Range and Value
Luxury becomes more attainable here, with prices typically 40%–75% below retail.
Features and Amenities
Conveniently located at Tuttlebee Plaza (3830 S. Tuttle Ave., Sarasota), the store offers several amenities to enhance your shopping trip. These include:
- On-site parking
- Wheelchair accessibility
- Free Wi-Fi
- Restrooms
- A pet-friendly policy
The store operates Monday through Saturday, from 10:00 am to 5:00 pm, and accepts credit cards for easy checkout.
Customer Recognition
Laura Jean's Consignments doesn't just excel in its product offerings - it also prioritizes the overall shopping experience. Sarasota Magazine has named it one of the top places to find luxury accessories at fair prices. With 36 glowing Yelp reviews, customers frequently highlight the excellent designer selection, well-organized displays, and friendly, attentive staff.
2. Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch
Specialties in Luxury Brands
Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch brings a fresh perspective to luxury shopping. This boutique offers a carefully curated selection of designer pieces, all personally chosen by owner Emily Hovermale. The store features high-end brands like Amanda Uprichard, Emily McCarthy, Ripley Rader, and Love the Label, embodying Florida's vibrant and stylish aesthetic with fabrics perfect for the season.
"At Monkee's, every piece is handpicked with YOU in mind - and my favorite part of this business is seeing our shoppers find something that makes them feel amazing." - Emily Hovermale, Owner, Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch
Whether you're dressing for a romantic dinner or a laid-back weekend, the staff is ready to provide personalized styling advice. The boutique has also become a favorite spot for mother-daughter outings, catering to a broad range of shoppers.
Price Range and Value
Expect to find designer pieces priced between $125 and $375. For instance, the Love the Label Eliza Tee starts at $125, while the Amanda Uprichard Lyra Midi Dress is priced around $268. Plus, orders over $250 come with free shipping.
Monkee's also offers private shopping parties for groups of 10 or more, complete with champagne and exclusive discounts. For added convenience, there's a $25 Fashion Concierge delivery service, which is credited toward qualifying purchases.
Customer Recognition
Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch has earned accolades in the "Best of Florida" awards for Clothing & Shoe Stores in 2023, 2024, and 2025. As part of a boutique franchise established in 1995 with over 60 locations nationwide, this store - located in Waterside Place - regularly hosts community events like charity fashion shows, solidifying its role as a local favorite.
This boutique adds a distinctive flair to Lakewood Ranch’s upscale shopping scene, blending style, community, and a personalized touch.
3. Burns Mercantile
Specialties in Luxury Brands
Burns Mercantile brings a fresh perspective to luxury consignment, focusing on artisanal, handmade goods that reflect an outdoor-inspired lifestyle. Their collection includes one-of-a-kind items like handmade ceramics and a specialty coffee line under the "Camp Grounds" label.
The boutique's apparel collection embraces a camp-themed aesthetic, offering items such as "Camper Stitch" pullover sweatshirts and "Good Quality Goods" puff print t-shirts. Beyond clothing, they feature artisanal stationery perfect for thoughtful gifts. This mix of handcrafted designs and reasonable pricing makes Burns Mercantile a standout in Lakewood Ranch’s growing consignment market.
Price Range and Value
Burns Mercantile keeps their pricing approachable, with handmade mugs priced around $36, sweatshirts at $64, and t-shirts ranging from $26 to $36. Specialty coffee bags are available for roughly $16, while smaller items and gift cards start at $4 and $25, respectively.
For added convenience, the shop offers an online storefront featuring a curated selection of at least 69 unique products. Their focus on handmade craftsmanship and premium materials - like unique ceramic glazes and high-quality puff print fabrics - emphasizes the value of their offerings.
Burns Mercantile brings a creative, artisan-driven flair to Lakewood Ranch’s luxury consignment scene, offering a perfect blend of style, quality, and accessibility.
Buying Luxury Resale? Everything You Need To Know
4. Woman's Exchange Inc.
Lakewood Ranch continues its streak of high-end consignment shopping with Woman's Exchange Inc., offering a shopping experience that feels more like an art gallery visit.
Specialties in Luxury Brands
At the heart of Woman's Exchange Inc. is a sprawling 15,000-square-foot showroom filled with authenticated luxury goods. The collection includes Gucci handbags, Tiffany silver, Baccarat crystal, and premium furniture from brands like Sherrill. Shoppers can also find oriental rugs, fine jewelry, and specialty art glass from renowned designers such as Kosta Boda.
The inventory is always evolving, thanks to the efforts of over 275 volunteers who carefully curate a selection of "affordable luxury finds". Shoppers can expect to stumble upon high-end brands sourced from Nordstrom, Neiman Marcus, and Saks Fifth Avenue, making every visit feel like a treasure hunt.
But the store isn’t just about luxury - it’s also about giving back.
Features and Amenities
Shopping at Woman's Exchange Inc. supports a greater cause. Since its founding in 1962, this non-profit has donated $10 million in grants and scholarships to local cultural organizations. In 2023 alone, the store awarded 17 scholarships and 29 grants. ASOLO's Artistic Director Michael Edwards summed it up perfectly:
"What they have done so brilliantly, is turn the act of shopping, into an act of generosity."
The store has earned its fair share of accolades, including being named 2016 Retail Business of the Year by the Greater Sarasota Chamber of Commerce. Even Lara Spencer from Good Morning America highlighted it in her book I Brake for Yard Sales as a must-visit destination.
Beyond its mission and recognition, the shop’s pricing strategy ensures there’s something for everyone.
Price Range and Value
Woman's Exchange Inc. caters to a wide range of budgets. Mid-tier brands from Macy's and Dillard's generally cost $35 to $150, while luxury items from high-end retailers can range from $150 to over $1,000. Examples include a Kosta Boda paperweight for $39.99, a Sherrill white sofa with gold nailheads priced at $869.99, and a 92-inch sailfish wall hanging for $797.99.
For bargain hunters, the store operates a markdown system: items drop 25% after 21 days and 50% after 42 days. This pricing approach allows savvy shoppers to snag incredible deals while contributing to local arts programs.
5. The Closet of Sarasota
Adding a modern flair to Lakewood Ranch's consignment scene, The Closet of Sarasota stands out with its accessible designer fashion. This boutique is a go-to spot for anyone looking to elevate their wardrobe without breaking the bank.
Specialties in Luxury Brands
The Closet of Sarasota showcases an impressive selection of hundreds of high-end brands. New arrivals are regularly added, keeping the inventory fresh and exciting for shoppers.
Features and Amenities
Every item in the boutique undergoes authentication, either by in-house experts or through trusted third-party services. For added convenience, they provide Seel Return Assurance, which offers a 7-day return option on eligible final sale items. Shoppers can also take advantage of Shop Pay, which allows payments to be split into four interest-free installments.
As of April 10, 2026, the boutique's dedicated website is in a "Launching Soon" phase, hinting at expanded online shopping options in the near future.
Price Range and Value
The Closet of Sarasota offers authenticated designer pieces at competitive prices. It's an excellent opportunity for shoppers to expand their wardrobe while participating in a sustainable, circular economy.
Shop Comparison Table
Here's a breakdown of five luxury consignment shops, designed to help you choose the best fit for your style and shopping preferences.
| Shop Name | Price Range | Specialties | Key Features | Customer Appeal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Laura Jean's Consignments | Mid to High-End | Designer clothing, accessories, home décor | Curated selection, personalized service | Boutique vibe with handpicked, elegant pieces |
| Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch | Mid to High-End | Trendy women's designer clothing (Amanda Uprichard, Emily McCarthy, Ripley Rader) | Focus on high-end fashion, contemporary brands | Perfect for fashion-savvy shoppers seeking current trends |
| Burns Mercantile | Affordable to Mid-Range | Eclectic mix of vintage and modern items | Unique finds with a community-driven approach | Ideal for treasure hunters and vintage lovers |
| Woman's Exchange Inc. | $40 – $900+ | Baccarat crystal, Tiffany silver, Gucci, oriental rugs, furniture | Massive 15,000 sq. ft. non-profit; 2016 Retail Business of the Year; 275+ volunteers | Supports local arts and students; featured in "I Brake for Yard Sales" by Lara Spencer |
| The Closet of Sarasota | Mid to High-End | Authenticated designer pieces, hundreds of luxury brands | Flexible payment options with four interest-free installments and expert authentication | Appeals to modern shoppers who value flexibility and authenticity |
Each of these shops brings its own unique flair, offering something special for shoppers in Lakewood Ranch. Whether you're after vintage treasures, trendy pieces, or authenticated luxury, there's a boutique here for you.
Conclusion
Lakewood Ranch's luxury consignment shops bring a fresh perspective to shopping, blending style, value, and community impact. Whether it's Laura Jean's boutique-style offerings or the expansive 15,000 sq. ft. showroom of Woman's Exchange - staffed by an impressive team of over 275 volunteers - these stores redefine consignment shopping. As Fine Resale of Florida put it, "Judith's dream represented a new bar of excellence for the consignment store experience, not only for the consignors, but for the customers too".
Beyond the allure of high-quality items, consignment shopping promotes sustainability. By choosing consignment, shoppers actively contribute to a circular economy, reduce fashion waste, and even support local arts programs.
From the vintage treasures at Burns Mercantile to The Closet of Sarasota's authenticated luxury pieces and Monkee's contemporary finds, each boutique offers something distinct. Together, they provide shoppers with curated selections that combine quality, style, and purpose.
FAQs
Which shop is best for authenticated designer items?
Fine Resale of Florida focuses on verifying and selling high-end designer goods. With their expertise, you can trust that every luxury item they offer is authentic and in top-notch condition.
When are prices marked down at Woman's Exchange Inc.?
Prices at Woman's Exchange Inc. drop by up to 25% once an item has been on consignment for 21 days. After 42 days, the discounts increase even more.
Do any of these shops offer online shopping or delivery?
Yes, certain stores, like Monkee's of Lakewood Ranch, offer online shopping and delivery services. Plus, they provide free shipping for orders exceeding $250.
